THE NATURE OF BARZAKH -No:38 - Dispute of the Soul and the Body


May ALLAH save us from the Punishment of the Grave

Dispute of the Soul and the Body.

In Islam, the soul and body are separate entities, with the soul experiencing a state of waiting in Barzakh after death while the body remains in the grave. Upon death, the soul leaves the body and is questioned by angels in the grave about their faith and deeds. The soul's experience in Barzakh, a period between death and resurrection, is dependent on how they lived their life, with righteous souls experiencing comfort and those who disobeyed facing torment. The body, though inanimate, is believed to be affected by the soul's experience, either experiencing blessings or torment in the grave.

The "spute of the Soul and the Body" and "torment of the grave" refer to Islamic beliefs about the experience of the soul and body after death, particularly in the period between death and the Day of Judgment, known as al-Barzakh. Ahl as-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah (the mainstream Sunni Muslim belief) holds that both the soul and the body experience punishment or blessing in the grave, according to the individual's deeds in life. This experience is not limited to the physical body but also involves the soul.

Here's a more detailed explanation:

1. Separation of Soul and Body:

Islam teaches that the soul and body are distinct entities, with the soul being the source of life and consciousness.

Elaboration:

Al-Barzakh is the realm or intermediary state between death and the Day of Resurrection. It is a period where the soul and body, separated at death, continue to exist and experience consequences based on their earthly actions.

After death, the soul departs from the body and enters Barzakh, a realm between this world and the afterlife.

The body remains in the grave, subject to decay, while the soul's experience in Barzakh is directly linked to its actions in life.

2. The Grave and the Soul's Interrogation:

After burial, two angels, Munkar and Nakir, question the deceased about their faith and deeds.

The answers given to these questions determine the soul's experience in Barzakh.

For the righteous, the grave is described as spacious, illuminated, and filled with blessings.

For those who lived a life of disobedience, the grave is described as constricted, dark, and filled with torment.

3. Barzakh and the Day of Judgment:

Barzakh is a state of waiting for the Day of Judgment, a period where the soul experiences either comfort or torment based on its actions in life.

The soul in Barzakh cannot change its fate or perform good deeds to improve its standing.

The Day of Judgment is the final reckoning where all souls will be judged by Allah based on their deeds and faith.

4. Punishment and Blessing in the Grave:

Islamic texts, including the Quran and hadith, indicate that the deceased will face either punishment or blessing in the grave (or Al-Barzakh).

5. Soul and Body Interaction:

The prevailing view among scholars is that both the soul and the body are affected by this experience. Some scholars, like Ibn Taymiyyah, argue that the soul can be connected to the body in a way that allows them to experience torment or bliss together, according to IslamQA.info.

6. The Body's Experience in the Grave:

While the soul experiences Barzakh, the body remains in the grave and is affected by the soul's experience.

A righteous soul's experience in Barzakh can bring blessings and comfort to the body in the grave.

Conversely, a soul facing punishment in Barzakh can cause the body in the grave to experience torment.

7.Evidence from Hadith:

Various hadith (sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad) provide evidence for this belief. For example, some narrations mention angels questioning the deceased in the grave, and others describe righteous individuals finding their graves spacious and comfortable while the wicked experience terror and constriction, according to IslamQA.info.

8. Protection from Torment:

Some hadith suggest specific actions, like reciting Surah Al-Mulk regularly, that can offer protection from the torment of the grave, according to Wikipedia.

Not a Second Chance:

It's important to note that the torment or blessing in Al-Barzakh is not a second chance for salvation or damnation. It's a consequence of one's actions in life.

9. Beyond the Grave:

The experience in Al-Barzakh is distinct from the final destinations of Heaven or Hell, which will be determined on the Day of Judgment.

10. Visiting Graves:

Islam encourages visiting graves to remember the deceased, reflect on death, and offer prayers for them.

Punishment of the Grave based on authentic Islamic sources:
Types of Punishment
1. *Squeezing*: The earth will squeeze the person's body, causing great pain and discomfort. (Tirmidhi)
2. *Burning*: Fire will burn the person's body, causing immense pain. (Ibn Majah)
3. *Beating*: The person will be beaten with iron rods or mallets, causing severe pain. (Abu Dawud)
4. *Animals*: Wild animals, such as snakes, scorpions, or lions, may be sent to punish the person. (Tirmidhi)
Causes of Punishment
1. *Not performing prayers*: Failing to perform the five daily prayers can lead to punishment in the grave. (Bukhari)
2. *Not paying zakat*: Failing to pay zakat (charity) can lead to punishment in the grave. (Abu Dawud)
3. *Committing sins*: Committing major sins, such as adultery, theft, or murder, can lead to punishment in the grave. (Tirmidhi)
4. *Not being truthful*: Lying, cheating, or being deceitful can lead to punishment in the grave. (Ibn Majah)
All

However, grave worship and turning graveyards into places of worship are strictly prohibited, as they can lead to idolatry, according to Islamic texts and scholars.

Hadrat Ibn ‘Abbas (may Allah be pleased with him) is reported to have said that the soul will dispute with the body and will say that the responsibility for all acts lies on the body. The body will say that it observed the orders of the soul and acted in the same way as the things were represented to it. God Almighty will say to an angel to settle their dispute. The angel will say that their case was analogous to that of a crippled and blind man. The crippled man informed the blind man that he had seen a fruit but it was beyond his reach. 

Then the blind man asked him to ride on him. The crippled man rode on the shoulders of the blind man and plucked that fruit. After quoting this example the angel will ask the soul and the body to tell which of the two was a transgressor. The soul and body will say that both men were equally responsible. On hearing it, the angel will say they were interdependent; whereas the body is a vehicle, the soul is a rider.

Hadrat Anas (may Allah be pleased with him) referring to a tradition, states that on the Day of Resurrection, the soul and the body will start disputing. The body will say, ‘“‘I was lying like the trunk of a charming tree. If the soul had not existed, I could not have done anything by stirring my hand or foot.”” The soul will say, “I was as light as air. If the body had not existed, I would have lost the power of doing something.” After this, the case of the soul and the body will be compared to that of the crippled and the blind man, as mentioned above. Then they will be held equally responsible. 

(Daraqutni Zawaid Kahid).






#PunishmentOfTheGrave

No comments: